Stay Updated! Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest blog posts & trends!

Eggshell vs. Gloss for Woodwork: Which Finish Should You Choose?

The Whims and Woes of Choosing the Right

So there I was, a sunny Saturday morning, sitting in my garage with a hot mug of coffee and a half- staring back at me. You know those days when you think you’ve got it all figured out? I had this brilliant idea of refinishing an old oak coffee table that had seen better days. It belonged to my grandmother, and I had so many fond memories of her sipping tea and playing cards over it. It felt like a piece of family history, just waiting for a fresh start. But as I sipped my coffee and gazed at the worn-out surface of that table, I realized I had a whole mess of decisions to make—mainly what kind of finish to use: eggshell or gloss?

The thought of choosing a finish felt almost daunting in that moment. I mean, how many people really stop to think about eggshell versus gloss? But trust me, it can keep you up at night if you let it. My grandpa always said, “If you’re gonna do something, do it right.” Not that he ever helped me with finishing, mind you. The man was more about big tools and projects than the little details like finishes. But hey, a is a lesson, right?

Making the Call

After a few sips of coffee, I finally got off my rear and decided to just dive into it. I’d heard a lot about eggshell finishes—they’re not too shiny but give a soft, warm glow to wood. Sounded perfect for that rustic coffee table vibe I was going for. Plus, I vaguely recalled that my grandma always preferred a nice, satin sheen for her furniture. So, there you have it. Decision made! Or so I thought.

READ MORE  Top Affordable Woodworking Projects to Try in Cedarburg

Fast forward a bit, and I was standing in the local hardware store, smelling the enticing aroma of wood stains and paint. It’s like walking into a candy store for grown-ups. I was browsing through all the choices when my eyes landed on a can of -gloss finish. It just… called to me. “A good shine never hurt anyone,” I remembered thinking, laughing a bit at myself. I grabbed it and added it to my cart. Next thing I knew, I had a glossy finish sitting against my better judgment at home.

The Surprising Reveal

Now, let me tell you, the first coat of that glossy finish went on like a dream. The way it glided across the wood—it was like painting with silk! But soon after, I realized I might’ve made a mistake. As I worked the brush over the table, I could hear a faint crunching, like little air bubbles getting trapped underneath. I almost gave up when I saw the first few imperfections; I thought, “Man, this is not what I wanted. Maybe I should’ve just stuck with eggshell.” But I have a tendency to push through, so I just kept going.

I shouldn’t have rushed it, though. It dried to a mirror-like finish, showing every tiny flaw, every—oh, I can’t even!—every speck of dust from my garage. It was like I’d created a huge magnifying glass effect on all the imperfections. At that moment, I wanted to throw the whole thing out and go back to just dragging the table to a thrift store.

Finding a Silver Lining

But then, after a night of sulking and contemplating my life choices, I woke up the next morning to that table. It gleamed in the sunlight, and I couldn’t help but smile a little. I mean, was I disappointed? Absolutely. But I also saw some beauty there—like a lesson taught and learned, right?

READ MORE  Create Your Own Desk: Easy Woodworking Plans for Every Skill Level

In hindsight, I realized that not every project is going to be perfect, and that maybe the flaws aren’t so terrible after all. I took a deep breath and thought, “This table may not be the picture of perfection, but it’s got character.” I could almost hear Grandma laughing it off in her own way, “Oh, honey, it’s still beautiful. Let it be.”

That morning, while sipping coffee and tracing my fingers over those glossy imperfections, something clicked. Sure, the gloss name might sound fancy, but eggshell was what my heart was really telling me to go for in the first place. It came down to personal touch, right? To this day, I believe that eggshell would have said “warm home” in a way that gloss just didn’t.

The Final Word

If you’re considering diving into your own wood projects, don’t trip over the details like I did. Go with what feels right. Maybe you’ll choose gloss, and maybe you’ll love it; maybe you’ll lean toward eggshell and get that you’re after. Just take a moment, breathe, and let your gut decide—because at the end of the day, it’s about enjoying the process.

We don’t always get it right, and that’s so okay. Life’s about those little lessons learned under bright, inviting sunlight while sipping coffee and laughing at our goof-ups. So go on, grab that brush, and make your own mistakes. You might just create something beautiful, flaws and all.